Arras when buying a home
Arras are the down payment you hand the seller when you close the deal, before the deed, and they count as part of the price. There are three types: confirmatory arras, which only confirm the purchase; penitential arras, which let either party pull out (you losing what you paid, the seller paying it back twice over); and penalty arras, which set in advance what the party in breach pays. The law does not set the amount: the parties agree it. If the bank turns down your mortgage, you only get the arras back if the contract provides for it; in Catalonia the law already lets you withdraw if the contract counted on financing and you prove the bank's refusal within the agreed period.
What arras are
The arras contract, also called a deposit contract, puts in writing the agreement to buy, the amount you hand the seller and the date of the deed.
- Binding from the agreement
- Once buyer and seller agree on the home and the price, the sale already binds both of them, even if nothing has been paid or handed over yet. The deed before a notary and the registration come later.Civil Code, art. 1450
- No notary needed
- A private contract signed by both parties is binding, whatever its form. A public deed is needed for the transfer, and either party can require the other to sign one.Civil Code, arts. 1278, 1279 and 1280
- Part of the price
- What you pay as arras is deducted from the price. At the deed you pay the rest.
- Its effect depends on the type
- What happens if someone pulls out depends on the type of arras agreed. It is the most important part of the contract, and it should be spelled out in full.
The three types of arras
- Confirmatory
- They signal that the purchase is closed and are a payment on account of the price. They give no one the right to pull out.Civil Code, art. 1124
- If you do not perform
- The seller can require you to buy or terminate the contract, and in both cases claim damages.
- If the seller does not perform
- You can require the seller to sell or terminate the contract, and in both cases claim damages.
Compensation is not set in advance: it is negotiated and, failing agreement, decided by a judge.
- Penitential
- They let either party withdraw from the purchase at a price known in advance.Civil Code, art. 1454
- If you pull out
- You lose the arras and the contract ends.
- If the seller pulls out
- The seller pays them back twice over: what you paid plus the same amount again. The contract ends.
- Penalty
- They set what the party in breach pays, instead of calculating damages.Civil Code, arts. 1152, 1153 and 1154
- If you are in breach
- The seller keeps the agreed penalty. Paying it does not release you from buying, unless the contract reserves you that right.
- If the seller is in breach
- The seller pays you the agreed penalty, under the same rule.
A judge can reduce the penalty if the obligation was partly performed.
If the contract does not say which type
- Under the Civil Code
- It has a single article on arras in a sale, and read literally it gives them the effect of penitential arras: if there were arras or a deposit, the contract can be rescinded by losing them or paying them back doubled. It does not say how to tell them apart from arras that are just a payment on account, which is what is argued over when the contract says "arras" and nothing more. Write the type: "penitential arras under article 1454 of the Civil Code", with what happens if each party withdraws, or "confirmatory arras, on account of the price", if neither party wants that way out.Civil Code, art. 1454
- In Catalonia
- The law presumes that the money you hand the seller is confirmatory arras, on account of the price, and penitential arras must be agreed expressly. If you buy in Catalonia and the contract says nothing, they are confirmatory and do not give you the right to withdraw.Civil Code of Catalonia, art. 621-8
- Which law applies
- That of the place where the home is, unless the contract expressly submits to another. A home in Barcelona, the Civil Code of Catalonia; one in Madrid or Valencia, the Civil Code.Civil Code, arts. 10.5 and 16.1
How much is paid
No law sets an amount or a percentage of arras for buying a home: buyer and seller agree it.
- If they are penitential
- It is what pulling out costs you, and what it costs the seller: the higher it is, the harder it is for both to withdraw.Civil Code, arts. 1255 and 1454
- It comes out of your savings
- The bank lends to you at the deed, so the arras are paid with money you already have. Include them in what you need saved.
- By bank transfer
- Pay them with a reference saying they are the arras of the contract signed on such a date, and keep the receipt.
Before signing the arras
The arras bind you from the moment you sign. This is what you should have checked beforehand.
- The nota simple from the Land Registry
- It says who the owner is and what charges the home has: mortgages, attachments, encumbrances.
- The seller's information
- Before paying any amount on account you can ask, on a durable medium, for the seller's identification, the total price, the floor area, the energy performance certificate, the certificate of habitability, the occupancy status and the charges, among other details.Law 12/2023, art. 31
- The Cadastre reference value
- Transfer tax is paid on the higher of the price and that value. Look it up on the Cadastre's online office with the cadastral reference.Royal Legislative Decree 1/1993, art. 10.2
- How much the bank would lend you
- The bank's binding offer comes at the end, at least ten days before the loan is signed. Before the arras you only have a simulation: that is why the financing clause matters.Law 5/2019, art. 14
What to put in the arras contract
- The parties
- Name and ID of the seller and the buyer. If the home belongs to a married couple, or is the seller's family home even if only in their name, both spouses sign.Civil Code, arts. 1320 and 1377 · Civil Code of Catalonia, art. 231-9
- The home
- Address, registry property number, single registry code and cadastral reference, with parking space and storage room if included.
- The price
- Total price, what is paid as arras and what is paid at the deed, and how it is paid.
- The type of arras
- Confirmatory, penitential or penalty, with the consequence for each party written into the contract.
- The date of the deed
- The deadline for signing before a notary, who chooses the notary and what happens if the date arrives and one party does not appear.
- Free of charges
- That the home is sold free of charges and up to date with payments, and how the seller's mortgage, if any, is cancelled at the deed.
- Community fees and IBI
- That the seller is up to date. The home answers for debts to the owners' association for the year of the purchase and the three before, and for unpaid IBI, even if the previous owner left them.Horizontal Property Law, art. 9.1.e · Local Finance Law, art. 64
- The costs
- By law, the seller pays for the deed and the buyer for the first copy, unless agreed otherwise. If something else is agreed, it should be written down.Civil Code, art. 1455
- The mortgage
- If you are buying with financing, the clause that says what happens if the bank does not lend to you.
- Handover
- That the home is handed over empty, with which furniture, and when the keys are handed over.
If you buy a home under construction
- Guarantee for what you pay
- If you pay money to the developer before the home is finished, the developer must guarantee its return with statutory interest, through surety insurance or a bank guarantee, in case the works do not start or are not finished within the agreed period, and collect it in a special account kept apart from its other funds. Ask for the certificate of the insurance or guarantee covering your payment.Law 38/1999, on Building Regulation, first additional provision
- VAT
- What you pay the developer on account carries VAT when it is paid.Law 37/1992, art. 75.Dos
What happens if you are refused the mortgage
It is the most common risk between the arras and the deed. It depends on the contract and on where the home is.
Under the Civil Code, outside Catalonia and unless a regional law has its own rule, there is no rule for a refused mortgage: what happens comes from the contract.
- Penitential arras, no financing clause
- You can withdraw, but you lose the arras.
- Confirmatory arras, no financing clause
- Not paying the rest is a breach: the seller can require performance or terminate and claim damages from you.Civil Code, art. 1124
- With a financing condition
- What was agreed applies: if the purchase depends on the bank lending to you, the obligation hangs on that event.Civil Code, arts. 1113 and 1114
- A useful financing clause
- It states, at least, the loan amount you are counting on, the period in which you must obtain it, how you prove the refusal (in writing from the bank) and that in that case the contract is terminated and the seller returns the arras. If you bring the refusal on yourself, for example by not giving the bank your documents, the condition is treated as met.Civil Code, art. 1119
In Catalonia the law already covers the case.
- You can withdraw
- If the contract provides that a credit institution will finance all or part of the price, you can withdraw, unless agreed otherwise, if you prove in writing, within the agreed period, the institution's refusal to grant the financing, unless the refusal stems from your own negligence. The seller returns what you have paid and, if they were penitential, the arras.Civil Code of Catalonia, art. 621-49
- Three conditions
- The contract must mention the financing, there must be an agreed period and you must prove the refusal in writing. Put it in the contract, with the name of the bank or banks you will apply to for the loan.
- Arras before a notary
- Penitential arras agreed for a maximum of six months and deposited with a notary can be entered in the Land Registry, and the home is then charged with their return. If someone withdraws, the notary hands the arras to whoever is entitled.Civil Code of Catalonia, art. 621-8.3
The example: a €250,000 flat in Sants
An example with round figures; the arras amount was chosen by the parties. Laura buys a resale flat in Sants, in Barcelona, for €250,000. She signs a penitential arras contract for €25,000 with the deed in three months, and a clause saying she will apply to a named bank for a €200,000 mortgage and that, if the bank refuses in writing within the first two months, the contract is terminated.
- Everything goes well
- At the deed she pays €225,000.
- Laura pulls out
- She loses the €25,000.
- The seller pulls out
- Laura receives €50,000: her 25,000 and another 25,000.
- The bank refuses the mortgage and she proves it in time
- She withdraws and gets the €25,000 back.Agreed clause · Civil Code of Catalonia, art. 621-49
- The bank refuses, but she proves it too late
- The penitential rule applies: if she withdraws, she loses the €25,000.
If the contract just said "arras", with the flat in Catalonia they would be confirmatory: neither Laura nor the seller could withdraw by paying, and whoever was in breach would answer for damages.
If the flat were in Madrid and the contract had no financing clause, with penitential arras Laura would lose the €25,000 by withdrawing because the bank will not lend to her. The clause is what saves them.
Get verified once. Open every door.
Every home in your areas, in one list. Your documents, only for whoever you choose.
Building your profile and getting verified is free.
- You upload your documents only once.
- Agencies see your verified badge, not your documents.
- Your documents are only seen by the agency you give permission to, and you can withdraw it.
What people ask most about arras.
What are arras when buying a flat?
The amount you hand the seller when you close the deal, before the deed, on account of the price. Depending on the type agreed, they confirm the purchase, allow either side to pull out at a set price or set what the party in breach pays.
What is the difference between penitential and confirmatory arras?
Penitential arras let either party withdraw: you lose what you paid and the seller pays it back doubled (Civil Code, art. 1454). Confirmatory arras give no such way out: if someone is in breach, the other can require performance or terminate the contract and claim damages.
How much are arras when buying a home?
The law sets no amount or percentage: buyer and seller agree it. Bear in mind that, if they are penitential, it is what pulling out costs you, and that it comes out of your savings, because the mortgage arrives at the deed.
What happens if the seller pulls out after signing the arras?
With penitential arras the seller pays you back double what you paid. With confirmatory arras you can require the seller to sell or terminate the contract, and in both cases claim damages.
Do I lose the arras if I am refused the mortgage?
Outside Catalonia, it depends on the contract: with penitential arras and no financing clause, yes. With a clause that covers the bank's refusal, what was agreed applies. In Catalonia, if the contract provides for financing, you can withdraw and get them back if you prove the bank's refusal in writing within the agreed period.
Do arras have to be signed before a notary?
No. A private contract signed by both parties is binding. In Catalonia, penitential arras of up to six months can be deposited with a notary and entered in the Land Registry.
What happens if the contract says "arras" without saying which type?
In Catalonia, the law treats them as confirmatory, because penitential arras must be agreed expressly. Outside Catalonia, the Civil Code does not make clear when arras are penitential and when they are just a payment on account: write the type and what happens if each party withdraws.
Are arras deducted from the price?
Yes, they are paid on account of the price. At the deed you pay the difference.
Do both spouses have to sign the arras?
If the home belongs to both, or is the seller's family home even if only in their name, both must consent to selling it. Check in the nota simple who the owner is.
What happens to the arras if I buy off plan?
The developer must guarantee the return of what you pay, with insurance or a bank guarantee, in case the works do not start or are not finished on time, and collect it in a special account. Ask for the guarantee certificate.
Sources
- Civil Code, BOE-A-1889-4763, consolidated text (https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-1889-4763). Art. 1454: "Si hubiesen mediado arras o señal en el contrato de compra y venta, podrá rescindirse el contrato allanándose el comprador a perderlas, o el vendedor a devolverlas duplicadas." Art. 1450: "La venta se perfeccionará entre comprador y vendedor, y será obligatoria para ambos, si hubieren convenido en la cosa objeto del contrato y en el precio, aunque ni la una ni el otro se hayan entregado." Art. 1124: "El perjudicado podrá escoger entre exigir el cumplimiento o la resolución de la obligación, con el resarcimiento de daños y abono de intereses en ambos casos." Art. 1152: "En las obligaciones con cláusula penal, la pena sustituirá a la indemnización de daños y el abono de intereses en caso de falta de cumplimiento, si otra cosa no se hubiere pactado." Art. 1153: "El deudor no podrá eximirse de cumplir la obligación pagando la pena, sino en el caso de que expresamente le hubiese sido reservado este derecho." Art. 1154: "El Juez modificará equitativamente la pena cuando la obligación principal hubiera sido en parte o irregularmente cumplida por el deudor."
- Civil Code, arts. 1255, 1278, 1279, 1280, 1113, 1114 and 1119. Art. 1255: "Los contratantes pueden establecer los pactos, cláusulas y condiciones que tengan por conveniente, siempre que no sean contrarios a las leyes, a la moral ni al orden público." Art. 1278: "Los contratos serán obligatorios, cualquiera que sea la forma en que se hayan celebrado, siempre que en ellos concurran las condiciones esenciales para su validez." Art. 1279: "los contratantes podrán compelerse recíprocamente a llenar aquella forma desde que hubiese intervenido el consentimiento y demás requisitos necesarios para su validez." Art. 1114: "En las obligaciones condicionales la adquisición de los derechos, así como la resolución o pérdida de los ya adquiridos, dependerán del acontecimiento que constituya la condición." Art. 1119: "Se tendrá por cumplida la condición cuando el obligado impidiese voluntariamente su cumplimiento."
- Civil Code, arts. 1320, 1377, 1455, 10.5 and 16.1. Art. 1320: "Para disponer de los derechos sobre la vivienda habitual y los muebles de uso ordinario de la familia, aunque tales derechos pertenezcan a uno solo de los cónyuges, se requerirá el consentimiento de ambos o, en su caso, autorización judicial." Art. 1377: "Para realizar actos de disposición a título oneroso sobre bienes gananciales se requerirá el consentimiento de ambos cónyuges." Art. 1455: "Los gastos de otorgamiento de escrituras serán de cuenta del vendedor, y los de la primera copia y los demás posteriores a la venta serán de cuenta del comprador, salvo pacto en contrario." Art. 10.5: "a falta de sometimiento expreso, se aplicará a los contratos relativos a bienes inmuebles la ley del lugar donde estén sitos".
- Law 3/2017, Book Six of the Civil Code of Catalonia, BOE-A-2017-2466, consolidated text (https://www.boe.es/buscar/act.php?id=BOE-A-2017-2466). Art. 621-8.1: "La entrega por el comprador de una cantidad de dinero al vendedor se entiende hecha como arras confirmatorias, es decir, en señal de conclusión y a cuenta del precio de la compraventa." Art. 621-8.2: "Las arras penitenciales deben pactarse expresamente." Art. 621-8.3: "En la compraventa de inmuebles, la entrega de arras penitenciales pactadas por un plazo máximo de seis meses y depositadas ante notario puede hacerse constar en el Registro de la Propiedad y, en este caso, el inmueble queda afecto a su devolución." Art. 621-49.1: "Si el contrato de compraventa prevé la financiación de todo o parte del precio por una entidad de crédito, el comprador, salvo pacto en contrario, puede desistir del contrato si justifica documentalmente, en el plazo pactado, la negativa de la entidad designada a conceder la financiación o a aceptar la subrogación del comprador en la hipoteca que grava el inmueble, salvo que la denegación se derive de la negligencia del comprador."
- Law 25/2010, Book Two of the Civil Code of Catalonia, BOE-A-2010-13312, art. 231-9.1: "Con independencia del régimen económico matrimonial aplicable, el cónyuge titular, sin el consentimiento del otro, no puede hacer acto alguno de enajenación, gravamen o, en general, disposición de su derecho sobre la vivienda familiar".
- Law 12/2023, of 24 May, on the right to housing, BOE-A-2023-12203, art. 31.1: "la persona interesada en la compra o arrendamiento de una vivienda que se encuentre en oferta podrá requerir, antes de la formalización de la operación y de la entrega de cualquier cantidad a cuenta, la siguiente información, en formato accesible y en soporte duradero".
- Law 5/2019, on real estate credit agreements, BOE-A-2019-3814, art. 14.1: "con una antelación mínima de diez días naturales respecto al momento de la firma del contrato"; art. 14.1.a: the European Standardised Information Sheet (FEIN) "tendrá la consideración de oferta vinculante para la entidad durante el plazo pactado hasta la firma del contrato".
- Law 49/1960, on Horizontal Property, BOE-A-1960-10906, art. 9.1.e: the buyer "responde con el propio inmueble adquirido de las cantidades adeudadas a la comunidad de propietarios para el sostenimiento de los gastos generales por los anteriores titulares hasta el límite de los que resulten imputables a la parte vencida de la anualidad en la cual tenga lugar la adquisición y a los tres años naturales anteriores."
- Royal Legislative Decree 2/2004, consolidated Local Finance Law, BOE-A-2004-4214, art. 64.1: "los bienes inmuebles objeto de dichos derechos quedarán afectos al pago de la totalidad de la cuota tributaria".
- Law 38/1999, on Building Regulation, BOE-A-1999-21567, first additional provision: "Garantizar, desde la obtención de la licencia de edificación, la devolución de las cantidades entregadas más los intereses legales, mediante contrato de seguro de caución [...] o mediante aval solidario emitido por entidades de crédito debidamente autorizadas, para el caso de que la construcción no se inicie o no llegue a buen fin en el plazo convenido para la entrega de la vivienda."
- Law 37/1992, on VAT, BOE-A-1992-28740, art. 75.Dos: "en las operaciones sujetas a gravamen que originen pagos anticipados anteriores a la realización del hecho imponible el impuesto se devengará en el momento del cobro total o parcial del precio por los importes efectivamente percibidos."
- Royal Legislative Decree 1/1993, consolidated ITP and AJD law, BOE-A-1993-25359, art. 10.2: "si el valor del bien inmueble declarado por los interesados, el precio o contraprestación pactada, o ambos son superiores a su valor de referencia, se tomará como base imponible la mayor de estas magnitudes."